home     about ted     new car reviews     used car reports     bike reviews     video reviews     ted's features
2010 Volkswagen Golf 3-door
2010 Volkswagen Golf 3-door

If you’re a fan of small nimble econoboxes, the progress of the VW Golf over the past few years has been interesting to chart. After that whole "is it a Golf or is it a Rabbit?" fiasco, VW has gotten back into the business of manufacturing a competent, well engineered hatchback, that is, in many respects, a cut above its rivals.


Which is how things used to be. After all, VW popularized this genre of automobile, back in - what....1975? with the original Rabbit - and, despite the presence of models like, oh, the Mazda3, Nissan Versa, Toyota Matrix, and Hyundai Elantra, the Golf has always been a performance leader of this market segment. With the exception, of course, of special models like the MazdaSpeed3 or Subaru Impreza WRX. Econobox? Of course, but the Golf has a nice motorsport heritage and, in its various forms, has long been a staple at grassroots track events throughout Canada. VW even had its own racing series for the Rabbit, ‘way back when, and these days, is heavily involved in the Dakar Rally and TDI Cup, in Europe.


Anyway, the latest version of the Golf, propelled as it is by a 2.5 litre five cylinder, is a little hot rod. With some 170 horsepower pushing a 1376-kilogram two-door hatchback body, the three-door version with a manual gearbox can hustle from 0 to 100 km/h in about eight seconds, which ain’t too shabby. I did a few acceleration runs while I had this car and got pretty close to this time on a regular basis. Few of the Golf’s competitors can match these numbers. One note here; VW continues to sell the City Golf in Canada, which is essentially the former generation, featuring a 2.0 litre four cylinder engine, and a significantly lower price tag. If you want the five-banger, you have to plump for the non-City model.


Two versions are being offered this year: Trendline and Sportline. About $3000 separate the two, and the latter has bigger wheels and tires, a power sunroof, different seats, tighter suspension, heated front seats, and various other odds and sods. My tester, a base Trendline model, came with a five-speed manual transmission, but you can also order a six-speed automatic, for an extra $1400. There is also a five-door version of this car, but, again, it’s more expensive....by about $1000.


Standard equipment level with the Trendline is decent. You get items such as cruise control, air conditioning, remote central locking, and power adjustable mirrors. I’d love it if the aforementioned heated seats were standard issue as well, but they’re not. That said, you can order them for an additional $275. This is actually not a bad price, and kudos to VW for offering the heated seats as a stand-alone option (well, almost....you also get heated windshield washer nozzles), and not part of some expensive and convoluted "package". If you’re in the market for this car, get the seats.


Too often in this corner of the market, when you get behind the wheel of an econobox, that’s exactly how it feels: like you’re driving a cheap car, built to a price and missing even the most basic creature comforts. The Golf, on the other hand, has an almost upscale feeling to it. Aside from a little engine growl, it may be the quietest hatchback on the market with minimal NVH (Noise, vibration, & harshness), and I felt like I was in a more expensive car....excellent front seats (with a knackle!), tasteful interior trim, full instrumentation, and sensible ergonomics. Fold down the 60/40 back seat and you get a purported 1310 litres of storage space, which compares favourably with models such as, oh, the MazdaSpeed3, which has 1213 litres available, and the Toyota Matrix, which boasts 1399 litres. The Golf will also seat five, but that won’t be most pleasant of experiences.


Speaking of downsides, the major drawback to having a 170-horsepower five cylinder engine in this configuration is the resultant fuel economy....or lack of it. The Golf three-door with the five-speed manual is rated at 10.4 litres per 100 km in town by Natural Resources Canada, and 7.0 on the highway. These numbers are below just about every other competitor, although not by that much....the Mazda3 2.5 litre is virtually the same. Just for the sake of discussion, the City Golf is slightly lower.


And, at the risk of beating a dead horse, I must complain once again about VW’s accursed self-locking mechanism. This annoying feature catches me by surprise over and over again, and I think the next time I test-drive a VW product, I’m going to have it disabled. VW: make this an option, not a standard feature.


Would I choose the Golf over its less expensive stablemate, the City Golf? I like it, but probably not. After all, performance is nice, but in this market, economy rules.


AT A GLANCE


Type: Five-passenger subcompact hatchback


Base Price: $20,175; as tested: $21,540


Engine: 2.5 litre five cylinder


Transmission: Five-speed manual


Drive: FWD


Horsepower/Torque: 170 hp @ 5700 rpm/ 177 foot-pounds @ 4250 rpm


Fuel Economy (L/100 km): 10.4 city; 7.0 hwy, regular gas.


Alternatives: Mazda3, Honda Fit, Toyota Yaris, Toyota Matrix, Kia Rondo, Volkswagen City Golf, Nissan Versa.


 

 
Manufacturer's Site  Volkswagen
 
Small Cars 2011 Chevrolet Volt
2011 Nissan Leaf
2010 Honda Insight Hybrid
2010 Kia Soul
2010 Nissan Versa Hatchback
2010 Volkswagen Golf 3-door
2010 Volkswagen Golf
2009 Chevrolet Cobalt LS
2009 Honda Insight EX
2009 Hyundai Elantra Touring
2009 Mitsubishi
2009 Morgan Life Car
2009 Suzuki SX4 Sedan.
2009 Volkswagen Beetle Convertible
2009 Volkswagen City Golf Automatic
2008 Honda Civic DX-G
2008 Nissan Versa Hatchback
2008 Saturn Astra
2008 Volvo C30 2.4
2004 Mazda Mazda3
2003 Hyundai Accent GS
2003 Volkswagen Beetle Convertible


 search

home  |  about ted/links  |  new car reviews  |  used car reports  |  bike reviews  |  video reviews  |  ted's features